The Growing Spectacle of Job Lotteries


What happens when business no longer hires based on the knowledge, skills and abilities of applicants but, instead, distributes jobs through de facto lotteries?

 

joblotteries400My biggest concern about the future of professional/managerial recruiting is that knowledge, skills and ability (so called “KSA’s”) will change to accommodate the fact that more firms will hire through what could be called 'job lotteries' instead of traditional hiring. With traditional hiring there is at least an attempt to treat the applicant like a person. And there is some meaningful relationship between the KSA's needed for a job and the matching KSA's of the person hired.


But with job lotteries so many people are processed that the primary determinant of being hired is chance, not the KSA's any given applicant brings to the table. Arbitrary factors unrelated to KSA's might play the decisive role in who gets hired in a job lottery. The statistical basis for this claim relates to the Central Limit Theorem, which states that as a sample size (number of applicants) gets large enough, you can become increasingly confident that population characteristics (KSA’s) are fairly represented in your sample. One rule of thumb says that a sample size of just 30 is usually good enough. See:

 http://www.statisticalforecasting.com/central-limit-theorem.php


Job lotteries result in the commodification and depersonalization of applicants. I think that internet submission of resumes can contribute to this phenomenon. From the point of view of Game Theory (discussed elsewhere) it probably makes sense for a company to have as many applicants as possible. But there is an ethical dimension to this which becomes important when so many people apply for one position that the chance of being hired, regardless of your KSA's, is similar to the chance of winning a lottery.


I think companies should exercise some restraint and voluntarily impose time limits or applicant limits to prevent a job lottery type of situation from developing. Job lotteries waste the time of all applicants (except the 'winner'), demeans them, and distorts the process of matching the strengths of people with appropriate positions.


Companies that refuse to use discretion on this issue might be prohibited from advertising open positions in the classified sections. Instead, I would require that job lotteries be advertised where they belong: in the parts of the newspaper or online sites that refer to Bingo, pot luck suppers, and other games of chance.


As a tax accountant one interesting question for me is whether the cost of participating in a job lottery would qualify as a gambling expense, deductible to the extent of gambling income. See: http://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc419.html


Of course some job lotteries develop through no explicit fault of the company, and arise merely because a particular town or city is hit with very high unemployment and one position opens up. Yet even in these cases steps should be taken by the employer to prevent a job lottery from emerging.
See: http://abcnews.go.com/US/Economy/wireStory?id=7029793#


As the cost of processing and analyzing information continues to go down we should expect to see more job lotteries develop. Competition will intensify while the loyalty companies demand of their employees will remain the same. How much loyalty will companies show to their own workers? How much respect will companies show to future job applicants? Will the workers hired through these lotteries be valuable employees or mere mercenaries? Companies should be judged not only by how well they treat their own people, but by how well they handle the hiring process.

 

LEGAL DISCLAIMER

George Adams
Certified Public Accountant Master of Business Administration
Tel: (207) 989-2700 E-Mail: GeorgeAdams@IntelligenceForRent.com
450 South Main Street: The HQ of IQ
Brewer, Maine 04412-2339

©2015 Copyright George Adams CPA MBA. All Rights Reserved.

 

Business Cases:

Nucor Steel: Into the Storm

10-25-2011 Hits:3117 Company Analysis George Adams

Nucor Steel: Into the Storm

One of the largest steel companies in the U.S.had a forty year track record of unbroken profitability until 2009. How can Nucor succeed in a tougher, harsher climate?

Read more

RITZ-CARLTON (Circa 2008)

12-15-2011 Hits:3323 Company Analysis George Adams

RITZ-CARLTON (Circa 2008)

 The business strategy of luxury with a human face requires both popularity and exclusivity. How can Ritz-Carlton master this apparent contradiction?

Read more

SAS Company Analysis (Circa 1995)

12-13-2011 Hits:2786 Company Analysis George Adams

SAS Company Analysis (Circa 1995)

Does it pay to fly dirty?

Read more

Otis Elevator (Circa 2004)

12-13-2011 Hits:4086 Company Analysis George Adams

Otis Elevator (Circa 2004)

The largest elevator company in the world has to make some tough choices.

Read more

Vertex Company Analysis (Circa 2003)

12-27-2011 Hits:2319 Company Analysis George Adams

Vertex Company Analysis (Circa 2003)

Crucial business decisions can benefit from the insights of combinatoric analysis.

Read more

Walmart Company Analysis (Circa 2003)

12-27-2011 Hits:2370 Company Analysis George Adams

Walmart Company Analysis (Circa 2003)

The largest retailer in the world is getting too big to grow any further without new and better thinking.

Read more

Sara Lee Corporation (Circa 2008)

12-27-2011 Hits:2320 Company Analysis George Adams

Sara Lee Corporation (Circa 2008)

Nobody doesn’t like Sara Lee, until the company started hating itself.

Read more

Southwest Airlines (Circa 2010)

12-27-2011 Hits:2603 Company Analysis George Adams

Southwest Airlines (Circa 2010)

How can the most successful U.S. airline keep it up?

Read more

The Power to Save the World: Fusion, the Unknown Ideal

12-28-2012 Hits:3268 Company Analysis George Adams

The Power to Save the World: Fusion, the Unknown Ideal

Energy is the ultimate question of our time: how do we get it, at what cost and what consequences?

Read more

Business Issues:

IT'S TAX TIME AGAIN

02-03-2017 Hits:967 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

IT'S TAX TIME AGAIN

The 2017 tax filing season opened on Monday, January 23rd when the IRS began processing returns.

Read more

HOW TRUMP DID IT

11-09-2016 Hits:1215 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

HOW TRUMP DID IT

This article is strictly non-political and explains how the billionaire Donald Trump legally avoided income taxes for many years.

Read more

WHAT RECORDS SHOULD YOU GIVE YOUR ACCOUNTANT?

01-13-2017 Hits:1093 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

WHAT RECORDS SHOULD YOU GIVE YOUR ACCOUNTANT?

For many people it's not obvious what records and information their accountant needs. This article will discuss the most important information your accountant must know when it's time to do your taxes.

Read more

BEWARE OF DARK CARS

01-13-2017 Hits:889 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

BEWARE OF DARK CARS

One phenomenon that began in the last few years in Central Maine is dark cars

Read more

YEAR END TAX PLANNING

11-29-2015 Hits:1893 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

YEAR END TAX PLANNING

Once more it’s time to play another deep game of chess with the IRS. Are you ready? The clock is ticking....

Read more

Why Are You Using An LLC?

05-20-2012 Hits:5366 Business Issue Analysis Administrator

Why Are You Using An LLC?

It can cost you a fortune if you choose the wrong entity for your business.

Read more

Pi and Pi Squared

10-31-2011 Hits:5447 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

Pi and Pi Squared

How can companies motivate innovation and manage internal conflict effectively?

Read more

Secret Unions: Employee Collusion and Conspiracy

10-25-2011 Hits:5616 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

Secret Unions: Employee Collusion and Conspiracy

Anyone can use Game Theory to try to get ahead. But sometimes there is a better, simpler strategy.

Read more

Jump! Employee Performance On Trial

10-31-2011 Hits:5206 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

Jump! Employee Performance On Trial

The true and the obvious frequently differ, especially when it comes to assessing employee performance.

Read more

You Have to Break Eggs to Make an Omelet

11-30-2011 Hits:4857 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

You Have to Break Eggs to Make an Omelet

Some employees take their work seriously while others don’t.

Read more

The Fallacy of Teamwork Part I: Train of Thought

11-30-2011 Hits:5816 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

The Fallacy of Teamwork Part I: Train of Thought

Is teamwork the answer to every business problem?

Read more

The Fallacy of Teamwork Part II: Michael Jordan Doesn’t Need a Memo

11-30-2011 Hits:6651 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

The Fallacy of Teamwork Part II: Michael Jordan Doesn’t Need a Memo

What does neuroscience have to say about the applicability of the team sports model to business collaboration?

Read more

On the Relative Importance of Sales People and Technical People to Business

11-30-2011 Hits:5274 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

On the Relative Importance of Sales People and Technical People to Business

Is it really true that technical employees are just a bunch of nerds a company puts up with so its star sales people can make big profits?

Read more

Business Cannot Ignore Its Environment

11-30-2011 Hits:5267 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

Business Cannot Ignore Its Environment

The power of goodwill to destroy the most successful companies.

Read more

Artificial Intelligence

11-30-2011 Hits:7182 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

Artificial Intelligence

There is nothing new under the sun, until computers become smarter than the smartest person.

Read more

The Growing Spectacle of Job Lotteries

11-30-2011 Hits:5214 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

The Growing Spectacle of Job Lotteries

A new take on the growing commodification of labor.

Read more

Understanding Tax Clients

06-05-2012 Hits:3442 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

Understanding Tax Clients

The primary cliché of our profession of taxes and accounting is that every client is different.

Read more

Making Business Succeed, Part One: Winning at Retail

06-26-2013 Hits:3657 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

Making Business Succeed, Part One: Winning at Retail

What you don't know may put you out of business.

Read more

Making Business Succeed, Part Two: Fresh Thinking For Farmers

07-23-2013 Hits:2944 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

Making Business Succeed, Part Two: Fresh Thinking For Farmers

There are many reasons for having faith in a seed.

Read more

Making Business Succeed, Part Three: Succeeding with Services

09-05-2013 Hits:5109 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

Making Business Succeed, Part Three: Succeeding with Services

Your journey to success will have many twists and turns. Here are important insights to guide you to success with your service business.

Read more

Making Business Succeed, Part Four: Victory for Vacationland

09-26-2013 Hits:3391 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

Making Business Succeed, Part Four: Victory for Vacationland

Tourism and related businesses dominate the economy of Vacationland.

Read more

Five Key Facts of Life for Non­‐Profits

08-14-2013 Hits:4119 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

Five Key Facts of Life for Non­‐Profits

You may be the last line of defense for your non-profit organization.

Read more

CLOUDY, WITH A CHANCE OF PAIN

07-31-2014 Hits:3831 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

CLOUDY, WITH A CHANCE OF PAIN

The truth about cloud-based accounting and the dangers of bundling.

Read more

TAX RETURN FRAUD IS RAMPANT

04-26-2015 Hits:2178 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

TAX RETURN FRAUD IS RAMPANT

According to a January 2015 news release from the IRS, for the period 2011 – 2014 the tax agency stopped 19 million suspicious tax returns and prevented the issuance of approximately $63 billion in phony refunds.

Read more

GEORGE'S POWER BREAKFAST

01-17-2016 Hits:3262 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

GEORGE'S POWER BREAKFAST

Business owners are the nucleus of their business, the center upon which everything else depends. It is frequently the case that business owners simply can't afford to get sick. Healthy food is the best preventative medicine of all.

Read more

GHOST ASSETS

10-27-2016 Hits:1090 Business Issue Analysis George Adams

GHOST ASSETS

Are You Being Haunted By Them? If You Are It’s Costing You Money

Read more

 

Contact Me

Member

Telephone: (207) 989-2700
Fax: 1-866-444-0032
Email - georgeadams@intelligenceforrent.com
Address: 450 South Main Street: The HQ of IQ
               Brewer Maine 04412-2339

Maine Society of Certified Public Accountants
Certified QuickBooks Professional Advisor
Bangor Region Chamber of Commerce
Beta Gamma Sigma and Phi Kappa Phi
National Association of Independent Writers and Editors
Published Contributing Writer-Maine Eagle Magazine
New England Peer Review

 

© 2017 Copyright George Adams CPA MBA. All Rights Reserved.
George Adams - More Than Just a CPASM